The coach clapped him on the shoulder. “Great hustle, Mark, but we’re moving you to the bench.” Mark’s face fell. He’d always been a starter, a vital part of the team. Now, he was supposed to watch from the sidelines. The words felt like a judgment.

Each practice was torture. He felt the sting of exclusion, the feeling that he was no longer good enough. He heard the coach’s instructions, but none of them were meant for him. He replayed his mistakes over and over in his head.

He became withdrawn and avoided his teammates. He felt a deep sense of inadequacy, a feeling that he had let everyone down. The silence of the bench was deafening, a constant reminder of his perceived failings.

Emotion: self-critical

Cluster: Shame / Guilt
PC1 (Valence): -1.66 Negative
PC2 (Disposition): 1.28

Role in Research

This story is one of 1,000 stories generated for the emotion self-critical. During extraction, it was fed through Gemma4-31B and its hidden state activations were captured at 11 layers.

The mean activation across all 1,000 self-critical stories, after denoising with neutral dialogue baselines, produces the self-critical emotion vector -- a direction in the model's 5,376-dimensional representation space.

Logit Lens (Layer 40)

Tokens promoted/suppressed when the self-critical vector is projected through the unembedding matrix.

Promoted:
L0.748
S0.662
ness0.425
ly0.374
0.351
Suppressed:
la-0.492
soon-0.304
(!)-0.301
secured-0.284
cautiously-0.280