Listen: Google Reclassifies Certain Types of Thin Content Pages
On 25 October 2014 Google Webmaster Tools stopped flagging a deliberately blank test page for a non-informative title and listed it as a soft 404 instead. The same shift showed up across tag pages, zero-result author and internal search pages, and other ultra-thin pages on several sites, some of the
Transcript
Recent data reveals that a Google algorithm update in late October was not actually part of the gradual Penguin rollout. Instead, the change focused heavily on on-page factors, specifically how Google treats thin content. Webmasters noticed that pages previously flagged for thin content or uninformative titles suddenly vanished from those categories. Instead, they began popping up in crawl reports as soft four-oh-fours. Google's algorithm appears to have reclassified these low-value pages. This shift affected a wide range of thin content. Affected pages included blank test documents, tag pages, and blog author pages with no actual posts. Even zero-result search pages and thin community forums were swept up in the change, flagged as soft errors even when they technically loaded successfully. While search marketers initially debated the cause, the industry consensus is that this was actually a Panda update. If you have seen a sudden spike in soft four-oh-four errors on your site, it is likely a direct result of Google reevaluating your thinnest and lowest-value pages.